Buckeye Reporter

In recent elections, anti-gun Democrats have often been perceived as condescending towards opposition voters, labeling them as misguided and prejudiced. This sentiment was recently echoed by former Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) during a debate at the Oxford Union Society in England on whether “populism is a threat to democracy.”

Pelosi's remarks were well-received by her audience. She described American populism as a form of “ethno-nationalism” practiced by individuals who show “negativity” towards immigrants and those different from themselves. Pelosi acknowledged that these individuals might have legitimate economic concerns but argued that their social views hinder them from accepting the Democratic Party’s policies. She referred to these people as “poor souls” with issues related to "guns, gays, God," which she claimed cloud their judgment.

This rhetoric follows a pattern seen in previous Democratic campaigns. In April 2008, then-presidential candidate Barack Obama addressed party donors in San Francisco, explaining why the party’s economic agenda did not resonate with voters in heartland America. He stated, “So it’s not surprising then they get bitter and they cling to guns or religion or antipathy toward people who aren't like them … as a way to explain their frustrations."

Obama's comments were criticized for portraying traditional values such as firearm ownership and religious belief as manifestations of bitterness. His primary opponent at the time, Hillary Clinton, condemned his remarks as “demeaning,” “elitist,” and “out of touch.” However, Clinton later expressed similar sentiments during her own presidential campaign against Donald Trump in 2016. Speaking at an LGBT for Hillary gala in New York City, she categorized half of Trump’s supporters into what she called a "basket of deplorables," describing them as "racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, Islamaphobic."

Clinton's characterization was met with backlash from Americans who felt insulted by being labeled deplorable and irredeemable. This sentiment contributed to Trump's unexpected victory in the presidential election.

Despite past controversies, Pelosi reiterated this perspective during her debate in Oxford. Her comments suggested that working-class Americans struggling economically may reject Democratic policies due to their attachment to traditional values like gun ownership and religious beliefs.

Pelosi won her debate in Oxford; however, it remains uncertain whether her party’s message will resonate similarly within the United States. Americans will have the opportunity to express their views through voting this November.

---